 |
| Purchase Information |
| Use this form to request purchase information on API online subscriptions. |
|
|
Document API PUBL 1645 is offered by IHS as part of an online subscription. This subscription contains many documents on the same topic.
You may also purchase this document alone from the IHS Standards Store.
API PUBL 1645 Document Information:
Title
Stage II Vapor Recovery System Operations & System Installation Costs
American Petroleum Institute
Publication Date:
Aug 1, 2002
Scope:
Stage II vapor recovery is a well-known air quality control measure that reduces ozone precursors
from gasoline dispensing facilities (GDFs). As a result of its relative high-visual profile, Stage
II vapor controls are sometimes proposed as a part of a regional air quality attainment strategy
without adequately comparing its overall cost effectiveness to other available control measures.
Changes in equipment technology and system testing techniques continue to raise new issues
associated with installing, operating and maintaining compliance of Stage II systems.
The purpose of this Stage II costs study partially comes from the U.S. EPA's more stringent ozone
standard that will bring additional metropolitan areas into non-attainment status. These additional
metropolitan non-attainment areas may consider Stage II controls as a priority air quality control
measure. As a further consideration, the U.S. EPA has also implemented an on-board refueling vapor
recovery (ORVR) requirement for new vehicles. It is designed to capture gasoline vapors at the
nozzle/vehicle gas tank interface during refueling.
Adding to the complexity of the matter, the California Air Resources Board (CARB), a
nationally-recognized lead agency in the certification of Stage II equipment and systems, has
recently promulgated major changes to the California Stage II vapor control program. This is
important because many states have linked their Stage II programs to the CARB equipment and system
certification process. However, this paper is focused on the current average cost of installing
Stage II vapor controls to meet the requirements of pre-EVR CARB approved systems.
This study considered three different types of retail gasoline outlet (RGO) vapor recovery systems:
1. vapor balance,
2. passive vacuum assist,
3. and active vacuum assist.
The "vapor balance" system, configured with a corrugated bellows over the nozzle spout designed for
capturing vapor, has been in use since vapor recovery was first required. The system has been
refined and upgraded with improving technology.
A more recent technology initially pioneered in the Midwest is the "passive vacuum assist" system.
Initial versions of this system used reciprocal vacuum pumps for each active nozzle powered by the
flow of gasoline to the vehicle fuel tank. Subsequent versions of this type of "dispenser-based"
approach use electrical pumps to return the collected vapor back to the gasoline storage tanks,
using electronic signals from the dispenser meters to regulate the vapor pump speed.
Finally, the "active vacuum assist" system has also under-gone many improvements since it was first
used. This system maintains a vacuum on the entire Stage II recovery system and processes the
excess vapor collected through a central vapor processor or burner.
A survey of API members and several other sources of information produced average Stage II
installation cost data representing company-specific typical Stage II system configurations for the
three targeted vapor recovery system types. The collected data was adjusted to conform to a
consistent refueling system configuration that should not be considered typical for the industry.
The equipment configuration used in this paper were an equalized number of nozzles, hoses,
dispensers and refueling positions for all three types of vapor recovery systems evaluated. [See
Table 1.]
About IHS
IHS (NYSE: IHS) is a leading global provider of critical technical information, decision-support tools and related services in a number of industries including aerospace and defense, automotive, construction, electronics, and energy. IHS serves customers ranging from large governments and multinational corporations to smaller companies and technical professionals in more than 100 countries. IHS been in business for more than 45 years and employ more than 2,300 people around the world.
